• Home
  • About

Evan Sparks's Aviation Policy Blog

A wonk's-eye view of everything in the sky.

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Happy Valentine’s Day!
A little presidential trivia for Presidents’ Day »

Oberstar on mergers: “Hell no!”

February 17, 2008 by Evan Sparks

In a BusinessWeek op-ed, House Transportation Committee chairman James Oberstar (D-Minn.) has come out firmly against airline mergers involving the big six.

Yet this latest round of rumored mergers, which includes a United-Continental scenario, as well as a Delta-Northwest combination, is significant. It would mean further consolidation in the airline industry, further reductions in choice for consumers, and probably fewer flights, fewer jobs, and higher fares.

I think Oberstar’s jumping the gun here. The Justice Department will do a full review of any proposed merger. (See here, and see my analyses of Delta-Northwest and United-Continental.)

Deregulation held out the promise of a market-driven industry that would give rise to a host of new entrants, bringing more competition, lower fares, and better service. The immediate aftermath of deregulation saw the expected flurry of airline startups and new market service. That activity, however, was short-lived.

Actually, deregulation did bring new entrants to markets, introduce more competition, and lower fares. Service may or may not have improved (premium service certainly has), but you get what you pay for. Lower fares are a form of better service. And what does he mean by “short-lived”? Changes in the industry have been pretty much constant since 1978. There has never been any shortage of airline startups and new service. It’s a very dynamic industry, and since deregulation, that has redounded to consumers’ benefit.

Meanwhile, the surviving carriers fattened up on the carrion of the failed and failing airlines.

This is a profoundly slanted view of competitive commercial activity. It imports visceral imagery to manipulate the reader into an emotional response — exactly what we don’t need in these discussions.

Delta’s home hub is Atlanta. Its most popular route is Atlanta-Orlando. Although Delta does not dominate service into and out of Orlando International Airport the way it does at Atlanta’s Hartsfield-Jackson, the airline does dominate the Atlanta-Orlando route, and Atlanta is the most popular point of origin for flights to Orlando.

He neglects to mention that AirTran operates nonstop between Orlando (its headquarters) and Atlanta (its main hub) about twenty-six times per day. Not that a merger with Northwest would change this situation anyway.

Two years later, United and US Airways announced plans to merge. I called on the Secretary of Transportation and the Assistant Attorney General to examine the merger vigorously, to look beyond the merger itself, and to consider the domino effect it would set in motion as other airlines sought to merge in order to compete.

So you trusted the Justice Department to wisely handle the situation then. So why throw a monkey-wrench into deals before they’re even announced?

Yet, I refuse to believe more mergers are the answer. Mergers may mean short-term profits for investors, but they inevitably mean long-term losses for workers and consumers. The merged carrier is never greater than the sum of its parts. It is always less, often much less.

Here, Oberstar is partly right. He is wrong that airline mergers have never produced value — there are any number of combinations that created strong, competitive national carriers (e.g. Northwest Orient and Republic or Delta and Western). But institutional investors like hedge funds have an interest in goosing the airline’s stock price, which merger talk does. They don’t necessarily care whether a merger produces long-term value.

We now have six major national network airlines in three alliances. Mergers that created value tied together networks to create national airlines. I’m not sure that there are efficiency gains that outweigh the costs associated with a merger. If you’re a regular reader, you know that I tend to pour cold water on merger plans — not from a policy perspective but from a business perspective.

But even though I’m a merger skeptic, I can’t endorse Oberstar’s conclusion:

This is not what we were promised when we deregulated the airline industry in 1978. If Transportation and Justice will not act to cool this merger mania, then Congress should.

If there’s anything worse than a bad business decision regarding a merger, it’s a bad policy decision. Congressional interference would have unforeseen consequences.

Airline Consolidation? Hell No [BusinessWeek]

Photo by Flickr user duluthquism. Used through a Creative Commons license.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Evan's Fiskings | Tagged competition, congress, continental, delta, Merger Mania 2008, mergers, northwest, regulation, united |

  • Recently on the APB

    • America vs. Europe: who overrates whom?
    • Scare headline not so scary in article
    • Crew rest and training, new ATC contract, and more
    • The solution to NYC’s airport woes?
    • And… I’m back
    • Nothing to see here
    • Let your left hand not know what your right hand is doing….
    • Evan around the web
    • This is just ridiculous
    • Liveblogging Randy Babbitt’s confirmation hearing
  • 2008 aerospace airports air traffic control alitalia american asia ata atsb australia pacific Aviation08 BAA british airways budget airlines business canada competition congress consumer advocacy continental delays delta Deregulation 2.0 dot emirates energy environment europe faa fedex general aviation geography health history humor iata icao klm korean labor latin america lufthansa media Merger Mania 2008 mergers meta middle east middle east/africa military misc. nationalism network airlines northwest open skies politics prestige regulation ryanair safety sarcasm security small communities southwest Southwest and the FAA space tax transit travel tsa united usa us airways virgin virgin america world
  • Archives

    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • October 2008
    • September 2008
    • August 2008
    • July 2008
    • June 2008
    • May 2008
    • April 2008
    • March 2008
    • February 2008
    • January 2008
    • December 2007
    • November 2007
    • October 2007
    • September 2007
    • August 2007
    • July 2007
  • Find me on Facebook!
  • Banner photo: Washington during landing at National Airport, November 2007. © Rachel Ayerst. Used by permission.

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

WPThemes.


Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Evan Sparks's Aviation Policy Blog
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Evan Sparks's Aviation Policy Blog
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
%d bloggers like this: